0000
Written
1873
Addressed to
1888

At present weapons are being changed every ten years, and even more frequently. In another fifteen years or so, people will use for shooting not rifles but some kind of lightning, some sort of a machine emitting a holocaustal electrical stream. Tell me: what can we invent in this line so as to surprise our neighbors? What if in fifteen years every great power will have secretly stored away one such surprise for any kind of eventuality? Alas, we are merely capable of imitating and purchasing ammunition from others, and—at best—of repairing it at home. To invent such machines we should have to have our own independent, and not purchased, science, not an imported but a free one—one that has taken root in our soil. As yet we do not possess such a science, nor do we even have a purchased one.

Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky

The Diary Of A Writer

Annotation

Dostoevsky's 'holocaustal electrical stream' was speculative, but his diagnosis of Russia's military-industrial dependency was surgically precise. The country relied on foreign arms purchases and licensed designs — Berdan rifles designed by an American, naval vessels built in British yards — and the gap became lethal at Tsushima in 1905, when Japan destroyed the Russian fleet with superior technology. Weapons did change every decade, as he predicted: the Maxim gun (1884), smokeless powder (1886), and modern artillery transformed warfare between the Franco-Prussian War and the Russo-Japanese War beyond recognition.

What Actually Happened

No 'holocaustal electrical stream' weapon appeared by 1888, though the machine gun (Maxim, 1884) and smokeless powder (1886) did transform warfare within his fifteen-year window. Russia remained dependent on foreign arms technology throughout the period — Berdan rifles designed by an American, naval vessels built in British yards. That dependency proved fatal at Tsushima in 1905, when Japan destroyed the Russian fleet with superior, largely domestically produced technology.

Related Entries

1924
expired0000

The Great War had been the explosion of a vast accumulation of energy, moral and social as well as material. Europe might, and probably would, bicker, murder, bomb, massacre, and starve, but for another generation at least she would not have either the spirit or the discipline or the material to produce such munitions and such wide-sweeping concerted action as devastated her in the Great War. She is morally and physically bankrupt and prostrate. She may go on sinking, as Asia Minor sank, back even to barbarism. Even if she does not do so, it will take forty or fifty years to reassemble energy for another such world-wide outbreak.

H G WellsWar & Conflict
1858
expired0000

The hordes are making daily inroads into the cultivated areas of Asia, spilling further and further beyond their natural boundary, the Himalayan mountain range that stretches from Bokhara to China. At our very gates, the hordes are surging all over Turkey. Fifty more years of persecution from the Ottoman Empire and we shall see the whole of that fine empire returned to the life of nomads or Tartars, who are making terrifying progress against Turkish domination.

Charles FourierWar & Conflict